Why Does Swiss Cheese Have Holes? Hay Dust, and a Court Case

The holes start at tiny hay particles in the milk. During ripening, the gas from fermentation gathers at these specks and grows into holes. Agroscope, the federal agricultural research centre, showed this in 2015. Modern closed milking systems let fewer hay particles into the milk, so Emmentaler lost holes, and since a court ruling of 2 April 2025 cheesemakers may add a hay flower powder.

Ask five people why Swiss cheese has holes and you get five answers: mice, air pumped in with a needle, a secret Swiss machine, or simply "bacteria". The last one is half right. The other half was only found in 2015, and ten years later it ended up in a federal court.

The half everyone knew

Emmentaler is a hard raw-milk cheese that ripens with propionic acid bacteria (Emmentaler AOP specification, BLW, in French). That fermentation makes gas, and the gas has to go somewhere. For a long time that was the whole explanation. But gas in a smooth paste needs a place to start, and nobody could say what it was.

What the scientists found in 2015

Researchers from Agroscope, the federal agricultural research centre, and the Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology (Empa) watched cheese ripen for 130 days with computed tomography, the same CT scan a hospital uses. They found that tiny hay particles in the milk are where the holes form, and that by controlling the number of hay particles they could control the number of holes (swissinfo.ch, 28 May 2015).

That also solved a second puzzle. Emmentaler had been losing holes. In the old days milk stood open in the barn and caught hay dust from the air. Today it runs from modern milking machines through filters straight into large tanks, so far fewer hay particles get in. Cleaner milk is a good thing for food safety, the researchers said, and cheesemakers who want holes can add hay particles (swissinfo.ch).

A cheese that went to court

Emmentaler with the protected designation of origin (AOP) may only be made the way its specification says, so adding something new needs permission. The producers' organisation, Emmentaler Switzerland, asked to allow a hay flower powder. The Federal Office for Agriculture refused and argued that the quality was still very high. The producers appealed, and on 2 April 2025 the Federal Administrative Court in St. Gallen ruled in their favour (judgment B-6947/2023).

The court said that easing the rules of an AOP must remain the exception, but that the producers had brought enough evidence. And since a cheese can also end up with too many holes, there was no danger that the powder would make all Emmentaler the same (Federal Administrative Court, 11 April 2025). The official specification now lists a powder that helps the holes form among the permitted ingredients, next to rennet, cultures, salt and water, as amended by the ruling and by a decision of the Federal Office for Agriculture of 4 November 2025 (BLW, in French).

What a real Emmentaler AOP is

  • Big. A wheel is 80 to 100 cm across and weighs 75 to 120 kg, about 90 kg on average.
  • Holes of 2 to 4 cm. Most of them round to oval, regular and clean.
  • Raw milk in a copper vat. The milk may not be heated above 40 °C before cheesemaking, and the cows may not be fed silage in the building where the milk is produced.
  • From one region. The cantons of Aargau, Bern (without the former Moutier district), Lucerne, Solothurn, St. Gallen, Thurgau, Zug and Zurich, and the Lake and Sense districts of Fribourg. It ripens there for at least four months.
  • Labelled. Every wheel carries the dairy's approval number, and every cut or packed piece must say Emmentaler AOP (or GUB, the German short form).

All of this is in the specification (BLW).

And now the robots

The same producers went back to court about something else modern farms changed. Many cows are now milked by robots, whenever they choose, and milk from just after the daily collection can be more than 24 hours old by the time it reaches the dairy. The specification says the milk must be processed within 24 hours of the oldest milking, and the producers asked for 29. The Federal Office for Agriculture said no, and the court held a public hearing on 22 June 2026 (Federal Administrative Court, case B-9250/2025, in German). When we wrote this, we had not seen a published ruling.

The holes were never just air. They were the barn, a speck of hay at a time, finding its way into the cheese.

More myths taken apart kindly: six Swiss inventions, the bunkers, and the rest of Swiss Mythos.

Frequently asked questions

Why does Swiss cheese have holes?

Because of tiny hay particles in the milk. In Emmentaler the fermentation produces gas, and the holes form where that gas meets these particles. Swiss researchers at Agroscope and Empa showed in 2015, with CT scans of ripening cheese, that the number of hay particles controls the number of holes.

Why does Emmentaler have fewer holes than before?

Milk now goes from modern milking machines straight into closed tanks, so less hay dust from the barn gets into it. Cleaner milk is good for food safety, but it left fewer starting points for holes. The Federal Administrative Court says the number of holes has been falling for about twenty years.

Is hay powder allowed in Emmentaler AOP?

Yes. On 2 April 2025 the Federal Administrative Court upheld the appeal of the Emmentaler producers against the Federal Office for Agriculture, and the official specification now lists a powder that helps the holes form among the permitted ingredients.

When we name a bank, insurer, telecom or other provider, it is because we think it solves a specific problem for expats. This is not sponsored content and we do not take commissions for mentions.